A Slice Of Brooklyn

3.7 ( 254 reviews )
$10–20
808 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557, United States
+1 717-355-0333

A Slice of Brooklyn is a hidden gem located at 808 E Main St, New Holland, PA, known for its authentic New York-style pizza that tantalizes both locals and travelers. Customers rave about their grandma pizza, which boasts a delightful combination of a crispy crust and a perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio. The friendly staff elevates the dining experience, making every visit welcoming and enjoyable.

Many patrons, like Autumn Labanoski and David S., express their affection for the fresh, flavorful dishes. David's review highlights the exquisite Stromboli and the kid-friendly cheese pizza—both devoured before a photo could be snapped! Another customer, Anthony Raffaele, further emphasizes the true NY-style essence of the pizza.

Whether you're stopping in for a quick lunch, like Jeffrey Little did, or making a special trip after a long drive, the positive experiences are consistent. The restaurant's attention to service and quality ensures that customers leave satisfied and eager to return. A Slice of Brooklyn not only serves comfort food but creates lasting memories, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Lancaster County.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Drive-through
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Comfort food
    • Private dining room
    • Quick bite
    • Small plates
    • Vegetarian options
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Counter service
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
    • Groups
    • Tourists
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking

Reviews For A Slice Of Brooklyn

Autumn Labanoski
Jul 2,2025
The grandma pizza is delicious and the staff is always so nice and helpful!
Jeffrey Little
Jul 2,2025
I'm in the area for work and swung in for a late lunch. Food came quick, burger was decent, and the gentleman behind the counter was courteous.
rageesalot
May 20,2025
Me and a friend were passing by after a 2 hour drive from NJ. The service was great. Waitress said that there was going to be await, expecting 20-30ish mins, but got served in about 10. The food was great, tasted super freash if I'm ever traveling here again. I'll definitely stop by A slice of brooklyn.
Anthony Raffaele
May 17,2025
A true NY style pizza !!! Thin n crispy with good sauce to cheese ratio !!! The best pizza in Lancaster county !!!
David S.
May 15,2025
We discovered A Slice of Brooklyn - New Holland today and it was absolutely delicious! This is real authentic pizza! We ordered a personal size cheese pizza and a Stromboli. The kids loved the pizza and the Stromboli was honestly one of the best I have ever had. The crust was crispy and full of flavor and the filling was top notch. The staff were friendly and welcoming and the prices were family and budget friendly. I wish I could have taken a picture of our food, but it was so delicious, we devoured it before I thought of taking any pictures! We look forward to visiting again!
Lee Godfrey
May 7,2025
Was an absolutely amazing experience. I'm a truck driver from New Mexico and had a stressful day dealing with loads and traffic. Got down here to New Holland just to find out my next pick up is closed till morning. So I decided to just go relax and this was just the place. The young lady working was amazing with great attitude and one hell of a personality. We laughed and talked about where I was from and finally decided on the grandma pizza which was amazing. Will be back if ever in the neighborhood
Cheryl Mack
Apr 15,2025
Ordered over the phone and they were spot on with their time estimate. Used the drive through which was nice because it was rainy. The Stromboli was perfectly cooked nice and crisp and golden. Waitress working the window was extremely nice and efficient.
Robert Perry
Mar 20,2025
this place was amazing the cheesesteak looked and tasted as good as it looked he gave us 2 garlic knots on the house and they where very good i would recommend very nice guy and place was good

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Ben's Plaice Looe
(324 review)
Ben's Plaice Looe
  • 1, Barbican Parade, Barbican Rd, Looe PL13 1EZ, United Kingdom
fish and chips restaurant
+44 1503 265221
Quackers Cafe
(365 review)
Quackers Cafe
  • Thornbridge Hall, Ashford in the Water, Bakewell DE45 1NZ, United Kingdom
cafe
+44 1629 640617
Chickadee Cottage Cafe
(318 review)
Chickadee Cottage Cafe
  • 317 N Lakeshore Dr, Lake City, MN 55041, United States
Cafe
+1 651-345-5155
Number One China
(359 review)
Number One China
  • 2549 Madison Ave, Montgomery, AL 36107, United States
Chinese restaurant
+1 334-269-1668
Lebanon Express
(785 review)
Lebanon Express
  • 327 Roncesvalles Ave, Toronto, ON M6R 2M6, Canada
Middle Eastern restaurant
+1 416-447-4417
Classic Bean
(693 review)
Classic Bean
  • 2125 SW Fairlawn Rd, Topeka, KS 66614, United States
coffee shop
+1 785-271-5005
37th & Zen
(793 review)
37th & Zen
  • 1083 37th St, Norfolk, VA 23508, United States
restaurant
+1 757-533-5151
CopperTop Tavern Vestal
(1788 review)
CopperTop Tavern Vestal
  • 4700 Vestal Pkwy E, Vestal, NY 13850, United States
Restaurant
+1 607-729-0164
Habibi Cafe & Sweets
(358 review)
Habibi Cafe & Sweets
  • 6520 Hayden Run Rd, Dublin, OH 43016, United States
Coffee shop
+1 614-319-3488
Hanover Pancake House
(2100 review)
Hanover Pancake House
  • 1034 S Kansas Ave, Topeka, KS 66612, United States
Breakfast restaurant
+1 785-232-1111